The safety and survival of a persecuted people, and a state’s duty toward them, stood at the centre of a landmark ruling delivered in The Hague on 19 November. The International Court of Justice found that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State during military operations in 2017. It is the first time the United Nations’ highest court has held a state responsible for committing genocide.
For the Rohingya, the ruling bears directly on their ability to return home. The court ordered Myanmar to make reparations, including facilitating the safe, voluntary and dignified return of those who fled. Myanmar must report to the court within two years on the restitution measures it has adopted and set out proposed compensation where restitution cannot fully repair the harm, though the judges did not fix a compensation amount. Myanmar must also provide assurances and guarantees that the violations would not recur.
The genocide finding passed by nine votes to six. South African judge Dire Tladi and fellow South African jurist Navi Pillay, sitting as an ad hoc judge in the case, voted with the majority.
The court found that Myanmar’s security forces killed thousands of Rohingya civilians, committed widespread sexual violence and attacked people fleeing towards Bangladesh. It also found that Myanmar imposed measures intended to prevent births within the group. Myanmar had argued that its military campaign was a legitimate response to attacks by Rohingya insurgents.
To establish genocide, the court had to determine not only what Myanmar’s forces did, but whether they acted with the specific intent to destroy the Rohingya, in whole or in part. The majority found that an intent to destroy a substantial part of the group was the only reasonable inference from the pattern of conduct. The scale and methods of the violence, the judges said, went beyond what an intention to punish the population could explain.
Crucially, the court did not abandon the test that genocidal intent must be the only reasonable inference when drawn from a pattern of conduct. It explained that genocidal intent can coexist with other aims. In other words, identifying a military objective does not, by itself, rule out an intent to destroy a protected group.
That distinction matters for South Africa’s separate case against Israel over Gaza, which alleges violations of the Genocide Convention and turns on the same question of how judges determine whether a state intended to destroy a protected group when it says it was pursuing a military objective. Israel denies committing genocide. The court made no finding about Israel’s conduct in Thursday’s judgment. The ICJ has issued provisional measures in that case but has not ruled on the merits. Under the court’s current timetable, South Africa’s written reply is due on 22 November 2027 and Israel’s rejoinder on 22 May 2029.
Meanwhile, in the Myanmar case, the judges also found that the state had failed to prevent genocide by individuals acting alongside its security forces, breached its obligation to punish genocide and failed to preserve evidence as required by a 2020 court order. They rejected The Gambia’s separate claim that Myanmar had directly and publicly incited private individuals to commit genocide.
The Gambia brought the case in November 2019 with the backing of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. In 2022, the ICJ ruled that The Gambia did not have to show it was directly affected to bring the case: every state party to the Genocide Convention has an interest in seeing its obligations upheld. Eleven countries intervened on questions of treaty interpretation without becoming parties to the dispute.
Thursday’s judgment is final and binding on The Gambia and Myanmar. It establishes Myanmar’s responsibility as a state, not the criminal guilt of individual commanders. That is also what distinguishes it from the ICJ’s 2007 judgment on Srebrenica, in which the court found that Serbia had failed to prevent genocide but did not find that Serbia had committed it.
What remains open is whether the reparations ordered on paper will translate into a real path home for the Rohingya still waiting outside Myanmar.