For 21 years, the fans who fill the Stade de France had waited to see their team beat the Springboks. Generations of players came and went in that time, sides that rose, fell and rose again, and none of them managed it. On Friday night they finally did, by the narrowest of margins, 21-19, and even then only by clinging on for the final 30 minutes while the best team in the world threw everything at them. The people in the stands crossed fingers and clasped hands as their team defended a seven-point lead, enduring an excruciating series of scrums on their own try-line in which the replacement pack creaked and buckled until Régis Montagne was shown yet another yellow card.
They had done it, remarkably, with a team that had barely won a lineout, lost almost every scrum and was missing a host of players. What they did have was Antoine Dupont. No fly-half? No problem. Earlier in the week, head coach Fabien Galthié had dismissed the idea that he and his opposite number Rassie Erasmus were playing mindgames as “comic-book stuff”. It turned out to be another bluff. Galthié had said Dupont would start at fly-half, and while the scrum-half wore No 10 on his back, he played the game in his usual position. It was his understudy Maxime Lucu who switched to play first receiver.
The match itself was full of twists. There were a fistful of cards, fantastic freewheeling tries, long stretches of intense scrummaging, a clutch of hugely controversial decisions by both coaches and the refereeing team, and at the very end one crucial missed kick: a conversion attempt by Manie Libbok that would have tied the scores with seven minutes left to play.
The French had made an occasion of it. Friday night at the Stade de France may just be the best show in sport. The pre-game was a full Cecil B DeMille production, with fireworks, flamethrowers, floodlights, a multicoloured drone show involving a three-storey cockerel that reassembled itself into a beating red, blue and white heart before transforming into a vast tricolore, and a performance by 150 dancers carrying LEDs to an earsplitting choral rendition of Like A Prayer. Astonishingly, the match lived up to all of it.
After 10 minutes of frantic tussle, the game took its first turn when Lood de Jager was sent to the sin-bin for a high tackle. France seized the extra space, and wing Aaron Grandidier-Nkanang came down the right side and dived through Damian Willemse’s tackle to score in the corner. Their next try had less panache. Dupont lashed a 50-22 up to the South African try-line, and as France spread the ball, Yoram Moefana’s pass hit teammate Kalvin Gourgues flush in the face and ricocheted over the try-line, where Théo Attissogbe pounced to touch it down. “I’m not sure how you prepare a defence for a ball that bounces off a guy’s face,” Erasmus said.
Erasmus had his own trick. An hour before kick-off he shuffled his line-up and dropped Ox Nché, Malcolm Marx and Wilco Louw to the replacements, meaning a French bench with three front-rowers carrying 25 international caps between them faced the gnarliest front row in international rugby. He pressed the detonator early, sending all three on in the 35th minute, an odd call given South Africa’s scrum dominance. They had already pulled a try back through a rolling maul, but Dupont immediately put Louis Bielle-Biarrey through with a tumbling grubber to restore a 14-point lead.
Then things unravelled. Lucu was yellow-carded for a high tackle, and Grandidier-Nkanang followed for slapping down a pass in the French 22, with Jasper Wiese shown a red in between for an illegal clearout. South Africa had a try struck off when Kurt-Lee Arendse was ruled offside after slicing through the defence, though Cobus Reinach bundled over after a rolling maul. The Springboks finally burst through near the end, but the ball was held up, and when Marx finished off a rolling maul, Libbok’s missed conversion kept France ahead. “We weren’t just outplayed, we were out-thought,” Erasmus said. “I’m not going to sit here and say I am going to take the positives, it feels shit.”
For the 21 years of hurt that ended on Friday night, the question now is whether this French side can build on it when the two teams meet again.